iPhone 11 Pro Max • Unlocked vs iPhone XS Max • Unlocked

iPhone 11 Pro Max • Unlocked
iPhone 11 Pro Max • Unlocked
Starting at

Refurbished price:$224.00

Versus $999.00 new

See options
iPhone XS Max • Unlocked
iPhone XS Max • Unlocked
Starting at

Refurbished price:$163.00

Versus $599.00 new

See options

Ratings

The iPhone 11 Pro Max, released in September 2019, and the iPhone XS Max, launched in September 2018, represent two generations of Apple's larger-screen flagship smartphones. Both devices offer a premium experience with expansive OLED displays and operate within the iOS ecosystem. The 11 Pro Max introduced notable advancements in camera technology, processing power, and battery longevity compared to its predecessor. Choosing between these models often comes down to prioritizing camera capabilities, extended battery life, or overall software longevity.

Scores

Durability

When considering the practical lifespan of these devices, their release timelines and Apple's typical software support cycles are key factors. Both models were built with durable materials and received high ratings for water and dust resistance at their respective launches.

  • Software Longevity: The iPhone XS Max, released in 2018, is expected to receive major iOS updates for a shorter period than the iPhone 11 Pro Max, which was released a year later in 2019. This means the 11 Pro Max will likely benefit from an additional year of the latest software features and security updates.
  • Physical Durability: Both devices feature a stainless steel frame and glass construction. The iPhone 11 Pro Max offers an enhanced IP68 rating, allowing submersion in up to 4 meters of water for 30 minutes, whereas the iPhone XS Max is rated for 2 meters for the same duration.
  • Repairability: Both models are designed with repairability in mind for critical components like the display and battery. The iPhone 11 Pro Max received an iFixit repairability score of 6 out of 10, while the iPhone XS Max received a similar score of 4.6 out of 10 from some sources, indicating that common repairs are feasible.

Release Year

2019

2018

Last OS Compatibility

Yes

Yes

OS

iOS

iOS

Foldable

No

No

Performance

The performance of these two large-screen iPhones is driven by their respective internal components, impacting everything from app responsiveness to multitasking capabilities. While both offer smooth operation, the newer model provides a noticeable boost.

  • Processing Power: The iPhone 11 Pro Max features a newer generation processor, which translates to faster app loading times, smoother transitions between applications, and more efficient handling of demanding tasks like video editing or graphic-intensive games. Users will experience a more responsive feel, especially with intensive applications.
  • Battery Behavior: The iPhone 11 Pro Max includes a significantly larger battery capacity, offering substantially longer usage times. Users can expect up to five hours more battery life compared to the iPhone XS Max, making it better suited for extended use without needing to recharge.
  • Multitasking and Storage: Both devices typically come with 4GB of RAM, allowing for competent multitasking and smooth switching between several open applications. Both models were available with storage options up to 512GB, providing ample space for apps, photos, and videos.

Memory

4 GB

4 GB

Screen quality

Both the iPhone 11 Pro Max and iPhone XS Max offer large, high-quality displays, but the newer model brings some enhancements in brightness and contrast.

  • Display Technology and Resolution: Both phones feature a 6.5-inch OLED display with a resolution of 2688 x 1242 pixels at 458 pixels per inch, delivering sharp and detailed visuals. The iPhone 11 Pro Max features a Super Retina XDR display, while the XS Max has a Super Retina OLED display.
  • Brightness Levels: The iPhone 11 Pro Max's display offers higher typical brightness at 800 nits and a peak HDR brightness of 1200 nits. In contrast, the iPhone XS Max has a typical brightness of 625 nits. This increased brightness on the 11 Pro Max improves visibility in bright outdoor conditions and enhances HDR content viewing.
  • Color and Features: Both displays support HDR (Dolby Vision and HDR10), wide color (P3), and True Tone technology for accurate color representation and comfortable viewing. The iPhone XS Max includes 3D Touch, a feature not present on the iPhone 11 Pro Max, which instead uses Haptic Touch.

Resolution

1242 x 2688

1242 x 2688

Screen type

Super Retina XDR OLED

Super Retina OLED

Audiovisual

The camera systems are a significant differentiator between these two models, with the iPhone 11 Pro Max introducing a more versatile setup.

  • Rear Camera System: The iPhone 11 Pro Max features a triple 12-megapixel camera system, adding an Ultra-Wide lens to the Wide and Telephoto lenses found on the iPhone XS Max's dual 12-megapixel setup. This Ultra-Wide lens allows users to capture a much broader field of view, ideal for landscapes or group photos.
  • Low-Light and Photography Features: The iPhone 11 Pro Max significantly improves low-light photography with the introduction of Night Mode, which automatically brightens and enhances details in dimly lit scenes. It also features an improved Smart HDR for better dynamic range and more natural-looking photos. The main wide-angle camera on the 11 Pro Max has a larger sensor that lets in more light, and the telephoto lens features a larger aperture.
  • Front Camera and Video: The iPhone 11 Pro Max upgrades the front-facing camera to 12 megapixels, capable of recording 4K video, compared to the iPhone XS Max's 7-megapixel front camera. Both devices offer high-quality video recording, but the 11 Pro Max benefits from improved stabilization and dynamic range.

Main camera

12 megapixels

12 megapixels

Front camera

12 megapixels

7 megapixels

Miscellaneous

Beyond core performance and display, several practical elements contribute to the overall user experience of these devices.

  • Connectivity and Ports: Both the iPhone 11 Pro Max and iPhone XS Max utilize the Lightning port for charging and data transfer and do not include a traditional headphone jack. Neither device supports 5G connectivity, relying instead on 4G LTE for cellular data. The iPhone 11 Pro Max includes an Ultra Wideband (U1) chip for enhanced spatial awareness, a feature absent in the XS Max.
  • Biometrics and Security: Both models rely on Face ID for secure facial recognition. The Face ID system on the iPhone 11 Pro Max is noted to be slightly faster than on the iPhone XS Max, offering a quicker unlock experience.
  • Physical Characteristics: The iPhone 11 Pro Max weighs 226 grams and measures 158 x 77.8 x 8.1 mm. The iPhone XS Max is slightly lighter at 208 grams and has dimensions of 157.5 x 77.4 x 7.7 mm. While the differences are minor, the 11 Pro Max is marginally heavier and thicker due to its larger battery and additional camera hardware.

Weight

8 oz

7 oz

Screen size (inches)

6.5

6.5

Network

LTE

LTE

SIM card

Physical SIM + eSIM

Physical SIM + eSIM

Carrier compatibility

Unlocked

Unlocked

Connector

Lightning

Lightning

User sentiment for both the iPhone 11 Pro Max and iPhone XS Max generally highlights their robust performance and premium build quality. Many iPhone XS Max users praised its large, vibrant OLED display and solid battery life at launch, with some noting its continued good performance years later, especially after a battery replacement. However, some users have reported battery degradation over time and occasional lag in demanding applications.

The iPhone 11 Pro Max is frequently lauded for its significantly improved battery life, with many users reporting it comfortably lasts a full day or more, even with heavy use. Its advanced triple-camera system, particularly the addition of the Ultra-Wide lens and Night Mode, received widespread acclaim for enhancing photography capabilities. Some users upgrading from the XS Max found the 11 Pro Max's size and weight to be a comfortable fit, despite being slightly heavier.

Users prioritizing an extended software support timeline, superior camera versatility, and significantly longer battery life will find the iPhone 11 Pro Max well-suited to their needs. Those who value a slightly lighter device and still appreciate a large, high-quality display for everyday tasks may find the iPhone XS Max to be a capable option. For consumers seeking a quality-assured refurbished option, both models offer an eco-friendly alternative to purchasing new, providing a reliable device for various user profiles.

See all articles

Our recent comparisons