Dell Latitude 5420 14" vs Microsoft Surface Laptop 5 15"

Dell Latitude 5420 14"
Dell Latitude 5420 14"
Starting at

Refurbished price:$251.00

Versus $799.00 new

See options
Microsoft Surface Laptop 5 15"
Microsoft Surface Laptop 5 15"
Starting at

Refurbished price:$584.00

Versus $1,524.00 new

See options

The Dell Latitude 5420 14-inch, released in early 2021, and the Microsoft Surface Laptop 5 15-inch, launched in October 2022, are both Windows-based laptops designed for productivity and everyday use. While the Latitude 5420 emphasizes business-oriented features and upgradeability, the Surface Laptop 5 focuses on a sleek design and a premium user experience. Both devices run on the Windows operating system, offering a familiar environment for most users.

Scores

Durability

When considering the long-term usability of these laptops, their release timelines and design philosophies play a significant role. The Dell Latitude 5420, being an earlier 2021 model, has a slightly shorter remaining software support window compared to the 2022-released Surface Laptop 5. However, both are designed with repairability in mind to varying degrees.

  • Software Longevity: The Microsoft Surface Laptop 5, released later, is expected to receive operating system updates for a longer duration, potentially extending its functional lifespan by an additional year compared to the Dell Latitude 5420.
  • Repairability: The Dell Latitude 5420 is designed to be relatively easy to repair, with accessible internal components like RAM and SSD that can be upgraded or replaced. The CPU, however, is soldered to the motherboard. The commercial version of the Surface Laptop 5 offers several replaceable components, including the SSD, display, battery, and motherboard, suggesting a commitment to extending its practical lifespan through maintenance.
  • Practical Lifespan: Both devices offer a solid build, but the Dell Latitude's more modular design for certain components might appeal to users who prefer to perform their own upgrades or repairs to prolong the device's use.

Release Year

2021

2022

OS

Windows 11

Windows 11

Performance

The performance of these laptops is influenced by their internal components, affecting how smoothly they handle daily tasks, multitasking, and more demanding applications. Both offer configurations suitable for general productivity, but their underlying architectures differ.

  • Processor Capabilities: The Microsoft Surface Laptop 5 features a newer generation of processors, which generally translates to more efficient handling of demanding applications and smoother multitasking. The Dell Latitude 5420, with its earlier generation processors, still provides capable performance for typical business applications and general use.
  • System Responsiveness: Users of the Surface Laptop 5 may experience slightly faster application loading and overall system responsiveness due to its newer processor architecture and faster RAM. The Latitude 5420 offers solid performance for everyday tasks, though it might not match the peak speeds of the newer Surface model.
  • Storage and RAM: Both laptops offer various SSD storage capacities, ensuring quick boot times and fast data access. The Dell Latitude 5420 allows for RAM upgrades up to 64GB, providing flexibility for users with intensive multitasking needs. The Surface Laptop 5 comes with LPDDR5x RAM, which is generally faster, but its RAM is typically soldered and not user-upgradeable.

Memory (GB)

16 GB

8 GB

Processor

Core i5-1145G7

Core i7-1255U

Graphic card

Intel Iris Xe Graphics

Integrated Graphics

Screen quality

The visual experience on a laptop is largely determined by its display. Both the Dell Latitude 5420 and the Microsoft Surface Laptop 5 offer clear displays, but they cater to slightly different preferences in terms of size, aspect ratio, and technology.

  • Display Technology and Resolution: The Microsoft Surface Laptop 5 features a 15-inch PixelSense touchscreen with a higher resolution of 2496 x 1664 and a 3:2 aspect ratio, providing more vertical screen real estate suitable for document work and web browsing. The Dell Latitude 5420 comes with a 14-inch IPS panel, with various resolution options up to Full HD (1920x1080).
  • Brightness and Clarity: The Surface Laptop 5's display is noted for being sharp and bright. The Latitude 5420 offers display options with varying brightness levels, including a 400-nit option that improves visibility in brighter environments. Some configurations of the Latitude 5420 may have a narrower color gamut.
  • Refresh Rate and Touch: Both laptops typically feature a standard 60Hz refresh rate. The Surface Laptop 5 includes a touch-sensitive display as a standard feature, while touch functionality is an optional configuration for the Dell Latitude 5420.

Resolution

1366 x 768

2496 x 1664

Screen type

IPS

IPS

Audiovisual

For communication and media consumption, the camera, microphone, and speakers are key components. Both laptops include these features, with some distinctions in their capabilities and user experience.

  • Camera System: Both the Dell Latitude 5420 and the Microsoft Surface Laptop 5 are equipped with a 720p HD front-facing camera. While functional for video calls, the Surface Laptop 5's 720p webcam has been noted by some as feeling dated compared to newer standards.
  • Microphone Quality: The Dell Latitude 5420 includes dual-array microphones. The Surface Laptop 5 features dual far-field Studio Mics, designed to capture clear audio during calls and recordings.
  • Speaker Output: The Dell Latitude 5420's speakers are described as offering clear and crisp quality with some bass. The Surface Laptop 5 incorporates Omnisonic speakers with Dolby Atmos, aiming to provide an immersive audio experience for media consumption.

Miscellaneous

Beyond core performance and display, several practical elements contribute to the overall user experience, including connectivity, physical design, and security features.

  • Connectivity Options: Both laptops support Wi-Fi 6 and Bluetooth 5.1 or 5.2 for wireless connections. For wired connections, both include USB-C with Thunderbolt 4 and USB-A ports. The Dell Latitude 5420 also offers an RJ-45 Ethernet port, a microSD card reader, and optional Smart Card and microSIM slots, catering to business and on-the-go connectivity needs. The Surface Laptop 5 includes a proprietary Surface Connect port for charging.
  • Weight and Dimensions: The Dell Latitude 5420, with its 14-inch screen, starts at approximately 1.37 kg (3.03 lbs). The 15-inch Microsoft Surface Laptop 5 is slightly heavier at around 1.56 kg (3.44 lbs), which is expected given its larger screen size.
  • Security and Build: The Latitude 5420 features a robust chassis with carbon fiber and magnesium reinforcement, and can include a fingerprint sensor integrated into the power button. The Surface Laptop 5 has an all-aluminum chassis and supports Windows Hello facial authentication.

Weight

46 oz

64 oz

Screen size

14

15

The Dell Latitude 5420 and Microsoft Surface Laptop 5 15-inch cater to distinct user priorities, each offering a compelling set of features. Users often praise the Latitude 5420 for its robust build, extensive port selection, and upgradeable components, making it a practical choice for those who value longevity and flexibility in a work environment. However, some users have noted its somewhat dated design aesthetic and potential for a narrower color gamut on certain display configurations.

The Surface Laptop 5, on the other hand, is frequently lauded for its sleek, premium design, vibrant touchscreen display with a productivity-friendly 3:2 aspect ratio, and enhanced audio experience. Criticisms sometimes point to its limited port selection and a 720p webcam that may feel less advanced compared to current standards. Real-world battery life for the Surface Laptop 5 has also been a point of discussion, with some users experiencing shorter durations than advertised.

Users prioritizing a highly customizable and repairable device with a wide array of connectivity options, particularly for business or IT environments, may find the Dell Latitude 5420 well-suited to their needs. Conversely, individuals who value a modern, elegant design, a high-resolution touchscreen, and a more immersive media experience might lean towards the Microsoft Surface Laptop 5. Both models are available as quality-assured refurbished options, providing an eco-friendly alternative for consumers seeking reliable technology.

See all articles

Our recent comparisons