Are Refurbished Headphones Good?
Get the best value and quality when buying refurbished headphones
When it comes to choosing the best headphones, sound quality, comfort, durability, and style are crucial factors. In 2024, with the headphone market more saturated than ever, it can be challenging to determine which brands stand out from the crowd. Let's take a look at the top 10 headphone brands of the year, considering expert opinions, Reddit user feedback, and overall brand reputation.
Sennheiser
Bose
Sony
Beyerdynamic
Apple
Audio-Technica
Beats
Jabra
AKG
Meze
To compile this list, I've analyzed multiple sources, including expert reviews, sales data, Back Market customer reviews and user feedback from communities like Reddit. The goal here is to provide a well-rounded view that takes into account the technical merits of each brand as well as real-world user experiences. Part of the research involved deep dives into Reddit threads like r/headphones, where audiophiles discuss their long-term satisfaction with various headphone brands. These conversations offer valuable insights into how these headphones perform in everyday life, beyond the controlled conditions of professional reviews.
Other considerations for these rankings include:
Sound quality: Prioritized brands with exceptional clarity, richness, and accuracy in audio, appealing to both audiophiles and professionals.
Comfort and fit: Ranked higher for brands offering ergonomic designs and materials that ensure comfort during long listening sessions.
Build quality: Considered the durability and materials used, favoring brands known for producing robust, long-lasting headphones.
Noise-canceling capabilities: Focused on the effectiveness of active noise cancellation, especially for brands like Sony and Bose that excel in this area.
Style and design: Evaluated aesthetic appeal and innovative design, giving extra points to brands like Meze known for their visually striking products.
Brand reputation: Factored in the brand’s overall reputation for reliability and customer satisfaction.
Additional features: Considered the availability of features like wireless connectivity, touch controls, and app integration that enhance user experience.
Price to performance ratio: Assessed whether the headphones offer good value for their price, ensuring the rankings include options that deliver premium performance without breaking the bank.
Why it’s ranked #1:
Sennheiser headphones consistently delivers on all fronts—sound quality, durability, and comfort. Their HD-series, particularly the HD800S, remains a favorite among audiophiles. Redditors praise Sennheiser for their longevity and reliability, often mentioning that these headphones can last over a decade with proper care.
Reddit insight:
One user noted, "My Sennheiser HD600 and Koss Portapro, both bought in the late '90s, are still in regular use." This kind of feedback reinforces Sennheiser’s top spot, proving that their headphones are built to last.
Why it's ranked #2: Bose headphones remain a top contender with its QuietComfort series, renowned for their exceptional noise cancellation and comfort. These headphones are perfect for those who prioritize a peaceful, distraction-free environment. Their sound profile is more consumer-oriented for average headphone users, but still highly respected among all types of listeners.
Reddit Insight: Bose is often praised for comfort and noise cancellation among different Reddit forums, making them a top choice for frequent travelers.
Why it’s ranked #3:
Sony’s innovation in noise-canceling technology, particularly with the WH-1000XM series, continues to set industry standards. Sony headphones blends superior sound quality with advanced features, making them a popular option across various demographics.
Reddit insight:
Though not as heavily discussed in terms of long-term durability as Sennheiser or Beyerdynamic, Sony’s tech-forward approach keeps them a top contender.
Why it’s ranked #4:
Known for their robust build quality, Beyerdynamic headphones like the DT-series have been described as "built like tanks" by many users. Their sound signature is also highly regarded, especially for studio use.
Reddit insight:
One user shared, "I’ve dropped my DT770s numerous times over the years, and they still work perfectly." The availability of replacement parts further extends the lifespan of Beyerdynamic products, making them a solid investment.
Why it's ranked #5: Since the majority of the US is part of the iOS ecosystem, Apple’s AirPods Max gets a top 5 spot on the list for its seamless experience for iOS users and blend of top-tier sound quality with Apple device integration. The comfort and style are also highlights, though the price points above $500 make it a higher end option. Ideal for those who are deeply embedded in the Apple ecosystem.
Why it’s ranked #6:
Audio-Technica offers a range of headphones that cater to both casual listeners and professionals. Their M50x model remains a staple in studios worldwide.
Reddit insight:
While not always in the high-end category, Audio-Technica is acknowledged for producing reliable and well-built headphones, which is why they’ve earned a spot on this list.
Why it's ranked Beats by Dr. Dre headphones, now owned by Apple, continues to appeal to the younger, style-conscious crowd. Their Beats Studio Pro headphones deliver powerful bass and sleek design, making them a favorite among those who enjoy listening to music on-the-go. While the technical performance and durability might not be the highest on the list, it's still a highly popular option for good reason.
Why it's ranked #8 Jabra headphones have made a name for itself with versatile models like the Elite 85h, which offer excellent sound quality and solid noise-canceling features at a more accessible price point of around $250 or less. These headphones are great for professionals who need reliable performance during calls and leisure.
Why it’s ranked #9:
AKG headphones offer a good balance between price and performance, making them a popular choice for both professional and consumer use. Their K-series headphones are particularly well-regarded.
Reddit insight:
AKG might not be as prominently featured in durability discussions, but their consistent performance secures their place in the top 10.
Why it’s ranked #10:
Meze headphones are celebrated for their design and craftsmanship. The Meze 109 Pro, for instance, combines aesthetic appeal with durable construction, and users appreciate the comfort these headphones offer during extended listening sessions.
Reddit insight:
One user praised the 109 Pro, saying, "After a year of daily use, some days for 8+ hours, they’re still as comfortable and reliable as ever."
You can buy headphones directly from the brand sites like the Apple Store, Sennheiser.com, Bose.com and others. They are also available for purchase from almost any major tech retailer including Amazon, eBay, Walmart, Best Buy and more. You can find them online or some sellers will allow you to try them on in-store before buying to make sure you like them.
Buying used headphones can be a good option for saving money, but the small savings may not be worth it since these tend to be riskier purchases because the device performance is not guaranteed and the condition is sold 'as-is'.
Instead, you should consider buying from a trusted and dedicated marketplace for refurbished electronics, where you can still save money, without sacrificing headphone quality. Back Market, for example, specializes in verified refurbished tech, so average quality of the headphones sold on site is much higher than general or used retailers.
For example, buying a set of AKG headphones in Premium condition from Back Market is like buying a new pair, but for a fraction of the cost.
You can save even more money and help the planet when you trade in your old audio tech, from headphones and earbuds to speakers at Back Market. We make the process simple and you'll receive a quote directly online within 1–2 minutes, which you can choose to accept. This is an easy way to keep old devices out of your junk drawers and our landfills, while giving you a little extra budget for your next purchase.
Choosing the right headphones in 2024 involves considering more than just the latest features or the brand's reputation. How you plan to use them and real-world durability, as evidenced by user feedback on platforms like Reddit, should also influence your decision.
Brands like Sennheiser, Bose, Beyerdynamic, and Sony have proven their worth through years of consistent performance. Whether you’re investing in a new pair or looking to buy refurbished, this guide provides a comprehensive overview to help you make an informed choice.
Miguel is always looking for new ways to provide unique perspective on popular tech and has taken his writing to the refurbished industry to promote sustainability. Outside of creating content, you might find him travelling the globe, coaching a fitness class, or cheering on his favorite sports teams (Go Dolphins!)