Galaxy S24 Ultra • Unlocked vs iPhone 15 • Locked AT&T

Galaxy S24 Ultra • Unlocked
Galaxy S24 Ultra • Unlocked
Starting at

Refurbished price:$575.00

Versus $1,204.00 new

See options
iPhone 15 • Locked AT&T
iPhone 15 • Locked AT&T
Starting at

Refurbished price:$347.00

Versus $729.00 new

See options

Ratings

The Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra, released in January 2024, and the iPhone 15, launched in September 2023, represent distinct approaches to high-end smartphone design and functionality. While both offer premium mobile experiences, they cater to different user preferences through their operating systems and hardware philosophies. The S24 Ultra stands out with its integrated S Pen and a versatile camera system, running on Android, whereas the iPhone 15 provides a streamlined iOS experience with a focus on camera enhancements and a compact form factor.

Scores

Durability

When considering the long-term usability of a smartphone, factors like software support and physical resilience are key. The Galaxy S24 Ultra and iPhone 15 both offer robust build quality and extended software update commitments, though with some differences in their expected lifespans.

  • Software Support: The Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra is notable for its commitment to seven years of OS updates, offering a longer period of guaranteed software longevity compared to the iPhone 15, which typically receives 5-6 years of iOS updates. This extended support for the S24 Ultra means users can expect newer features and security patches for a more prolonged duration.
  • Physical Durability: Both devices feature advanced protective materials. The Galaxy S24 Ultra incorporates a titanium frame and Gorilla Glass Armor for its display, contributing to its resistance against scratches and drops. The iPhone 15 utilizes an aluminum frame and a Ceramic Shield front cover, also designed for enhanced durability. Both models carry an IP68 rating for dust and water resistance, indicating similar levels of protection against environmental elements.
  • Practical Lifespan: Users prioritizing the absolute longest software support will find the Galaxy S24 Ultra's seven-year commitment appealing. However, both phones are built to last several years of typical use, with their respective update policies ensuring they remain functional and secure for a considerable period.

Release Year

2024

2023

Last OS Compatibility

Yes

Yes

OS

Android

iOS

Foldable

No

No

Performance

Evaluating smartphone performance involves looking beyond raw specifications to understand how devices handle daily tasks, demanding applications, and multitasking. The Galaxy S24 Ultra and iPhone 15 approach performance with different underlying architectures, resulting in distinct user experiences.

  • Processing Power: The Galaxy S24 Ultra is equipped with a processor designed for intensive tasks, offering smooth operation for demanding apps, advanced gaming, and AI-driven features. The iPhone 15 features a powerful chip that ensures fluid navigation, quick app launches, and efficient handling of graphics-intensive applications. Both devices provide a highly responsive user experience for everyday activities.
  • Multitasking and Storage: The Galaxy S24 Ultra typically comes with a higher amount of RAM, which can benefit users who frequently switch between many applications or engage in heavy multitasking. It also offers generous storage options, including up to 1TB. The iPhone 15, while having less RAM, is optimized to manage applications efficiently, providing a smooth multitasking experience for most users. Its storage options go up to 512GB.
  • Battery Behavior: The Galaxy S24 Ultra houses a larger battery capacity, generally translating to extended usage times for heavy users. The iPhone 15, with its smaller battery, is optimized for efficient power consumption, often providing a full day of use for average tasks.

Memory (GB)

12 GB

6 GB

Screen quality

The display is a primary interface for smartphone interaction, and both the Galaxy S24 Ultra and iPhone 15 offer high-quality viewing experiences, though with notable differences in size, technology, and refresh rates.

  • Display Technology and Clarity: The Galaxy S24 Ultra features a 6.8-inch Dynamic AMOLED 2X display with a QHD+ resolution, providing sharp details and vibrant colors. The iPhone 15 comes with a 6.1-inch Super Retina XDR OLED display, offering excellent contrast and color accuracy. Both technologies deliver deep blacks and bright whites, enhancing the visual experience.
  • Brightness and Refresh Rate: The S24 Ultra's display boasts a high peak brightness, making it highly visible even in direct sunlight, and an adaptive refresh rate that can go up to 120Hz for smooth scrolling and fluid animations. The iPhone 15 also offers strong peak brightness for outdoor visibility but maintains a standard 60Hz refresh rate. Users prioritizing smoother motion and a larger screen will find the S24 Ultra more appealing.
  • Screen Size and Viewing Experience: The larger 6.8-inch screen of the Galaxy S24 Ultra provides an expansive canvas for media consumption, gaming, and productivity tasks, including S Pen usage. The iPhone 15's 6.1-inch display offers a more compact and manageable form factor, suitable for one-handed use and those who prefer a smaller device.

Resolution

1440 x 3120

1179 x 2556

Screen type

Dynamic LTPO AMOLED 2X

Super Retina XDR OLED

Audiovisual

Both the Galaxy S24 Ultra and the iPhone 15 are equipped with advanced camera systems designed to capture high-quality photos and videos, but they differ in their hardware configurations and specialized features.

  • Camera System Capabilities: The Galaxy S24 Ultra features a versatile quad-camera setup, including a 200MP main sensor, a 12MP ultrawide, a 10MP 3x telephoto, and a 50MP 5x telephoto lens, offering extensive zoom capabilities. The iPhone 15 has a dual-camera system with a 48MP main sensor and a 12MP ultrawide lens, which also enables a 2x telephoto option through sensor cropping.
  • Photography Performance: The S24 Ultra excels in capturing detailed images across various zoom levels and offers advanced AI features for photo enhancement and video editing. Its large main sensor and multiple telephoto lenses provide flexibility for different shooting scenarios, including impressive low-light performance. The iPhone 15 delivers consistent and vibrant photos with strong computational photography, performing well in everyday conditions and low light.
  • Video Recording and Audio: Both devices support high-resolution video recording, with the S24 Ultra capable of 8K video and the iPhone 15 offering 4K video recording with advanced stabilization. Both phones provide clear audio recording and offer stereo speakers for media playback, ensuring a good experience for calls and content consumption.

Main camera

200 megapixels

48 megapixels

Front camera

12 megapixels

12 megapixels

Miscellaneous

Beyond core performance and display, several practical elements contribute to the overall user experience of the Galaxy S24 Ultra and iPhone 15, from connectivity to physical design.

  • Connectivity and Ports: The Galaxy S24 Ultra supports the latest Wi-Fi 7 standard, offering potentially faster wireless speeds, alongside Bluetooth 5.3 and a USB-C 3.2 port for quicker data transfers. The iPhone 15 features Wi-Fi 6E and Bluetooth 5.3, and has transitioned to a USB-C 2.0 port, which offers standard data transfer speeds.
  • Sensors and Biometrics: The S24 Ultra includes an ultrasonic in-display fingerprint sensor for secure unlocking and authentication. The iPhone 15 relies on Face ID for facial recognition, providing a secure and convenient biometric option. Both devices incorporate a range of sensors for navigation and user interaction.
  • Dimensions, Weight, and Build: The Galaxy S24 Ultra is a larger and heavier device, measuring 162.3 x 79 x 8.6 mm and weighing 233 grams, which contributes to its expansive screen and larger battery. The iPhone 15 is more compact and lighter at 147.6 x 71.6 x 7.8 mm and 171 grams, making it easier to handle with one hand. The S24 Ultra also uniquely integrates the S Pen stylus, offering additional productivity features.

Weight

8 oz

171 oz

Screen size (inches)

6.8

6.1

Network

5G

5G

SIM card

Physical SIM + eSIM

eSIM

Carrier compatibility

Unlocked

AT&T

The Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra and the iPhone 15 cater to different user priorities, each excelling in distinct areas. User feedback often highlights the S24 Ultra's comprehensive feature set, particularly its versatile camera system with extensive zoom capabilities and the integrated S Pen, which is frequently praised by those who value productivity and creative input. Its large, high-refresh-rate display and long software support commitment are also common points of appreciation. Some users, however, might find its size and weight to be a consideration for one-handed use.

The iPhone 15 is generally lauded for its streamlined iOS experience, consistent camera performance, and more compact design, making it a preferred choice for users who favor ease of use and a device that fits comfortably in the hand. The introduction of the Dynamic Island and the USB-C port were well-received updates. Some users note the 60Hz refresh rate as a point of difference compared to higher-end devices.

Users prioritizing a large, feature-rich device with advanced camera versatility, extensive software support, and the unique functionality of a stylus may find the Galaxy S24 Ultra well-suited to their needs. Conversely, individuals who value a more compact form factor, a highly intuitive operating system, and a reliable camera for everyday photography will likely lean towards the iPhone 15. Both devices offer a quality-assured refurbished option, providing an eco-friendly alternative for consumers looking to make a sustainable choice while still enjoying premium smartphone technology.

See all articles

Our recent comparisons