iPhone 15 • Locked AT&T vs iPhone 16 Pro Max • Unlocked

iPhone 15 • Locked AT&T
iPhone 15 • Locked AT&T
Starting at

Refurbished price:$348.00

Versus $729.00 new

See options
iPhone 16 Pro Max • Unlocked
iPhone 16 Pro Max • Unlocked
Starting at

Refurbished price:$759.00

Versus $1,199.00 new

See options

Ratings

The iPhone 15, released in September 2023, and the iPhone 16 Pro Max, launched in September 2024, represent different tiers within Apple's smartphone lineup. While both devices offer a premium experience, the iPhone 16 Pro Max distinguishes itself with a larger display, a more advanced camera system, and enhanced performance capabilities. Both operate on Apple's iOS, ensuring a consistent software ecosystem.

Scores

Durability

When considering the practical lifespan of these devices, several factors come into play, including software support and physical resilience.

  • Software Longevity: The iPhone 15 launched with iOS 17 and is compatible with iOS 18 and iOS 26, indicating a long period of software updates. The iPhone 16 Pro Max, being a newer model, ships with iOS 18 and is expected to receive software support for an extended duration, likely one year longer than the iPhone 15.
  • Physical Durability: Both models feature Ceramic Shield on the front for enhanced drop protection and are rated IP68 for water and dust resistance, allowing submersion up to 6 meters for 30 minutes. The iPhone 16 Pro Max incorporates a titanium frame, offering a different feel and potentially improved structural integrity compared to the iPhone 15's aluminum design.
  • Battery Health: Apple has indicated that the iPhone 15 series batteries are designed to retain 80% of their original capacity after 1000 charge cycles, a significant improvement in expected longevity. The iPhone 16 Pro Max, being a newer generation, is expected to maintain or further improve upon this standard.

Release Year

2023

2024

Last OS Compatibility

Yes

Yes

Foldable

No

No

Performance

Performance is a key area where these two iPhones cater to different user demands, particularly concerning processing power and battery endurance.

  • Processing Power: The iPhone 15 is powered by a capable processor that handles everyday applications, multitasking, and moderate gaming smoothly. The iPhone 16 Pro Max features a newer, more advanced processor designed for demanding tasks, offering faster CPU and GPU speeds, which translates to smoother performance in intensive applications, advanced gaming, and complex video editing.
  • Multitasking and Storage: The iPhone 15 comes with 6GB of RAM, providing a responsive experience for typical usage. The iPhone 16 Pro Max includes 8GB of RAM, enhancing its ability to manage numerous applications simultaneously without slowdowns. Storage options for the iPhone 15 range from 128GB to 512GB, while the iPhone 16 Pro Max starts at 256GB and goes up to 1TB, catering to users with larger storage needs.
  • Battery Behavior: The iPhone 15 offers up to 20 hours of video playback, providing all-day power for many users. The iPhone 16 Pro Max, with its larger battery capacity (4685 mAh) and optimized components, delivers significantly extended battery life, with some tests showing over 25 hours of video playback, making it suitable for heavy usage throughout the day and beyond.

Memory (GB)

6 GB

8 GB

Screen quality

The visual experience differs between these two models, primarily in screen size and advanced display technologies.

  • Display Technology and Size: Both devices feature Super Retina XDR OLED displays, offering deep blacks, vibrant colors, and excellent contrast. The iPhone 15 has a 6.1-inch display, providing a compact viewing experience. The iPhone 16 Pro Max boasts a larger 6.9-inch display, offering a more expansive canvas for media consumption and productivity.
  • Resolution and Clarity: Both phones maintain a high pixel density of approximately 460 pixels per inch (ppi), ensuring sharp text and detailed images. The iPhone 15 has a resolution of 2556x1179 pixels, while the iPhone 16 Pro Max features a higher resolution of 2868x1320 pixels to accommodate its larger screen size.
  • Brightness and Refresh Rate: Both models achieve a peak outdoor brightness of 2000 nits, ensuring visibility in bright sunlight. A key difference is the refresh rate: the iPhone 15 has a standard 60Hz refresh rate, while the iPhone 16 Pro Max features ProMotion technology with an adaptive refresh rate up to 120Hz, providing smoother scrolling and more fluid animations. The 16 Pro Max also includes an Always-On display.

Resolution

1179 x 2556

1320 x 2868

Screen type

Super Retina XDR OLED

LTPO Super Retina XDR OLED

Audiovisual

The camera systems on both iPhones deliver high-quality imaging, but the Pro Max model offers more advanced features and versatility.

  • Main Camera System: The iPhone 15 features an advanced dual-camera system with a 48MP main sensor that produces detailed 24MP photos by default, and a 12MP ultra-wide lens. It also offers a 2x telephoto option through its main sensor. The iPhone 16 Pro Max elevates this with a Pro camera system, including a 48MP main sensor, a new 48MP ultra-wide lens with Hybrid Focus Pixels, and a dedicated 12MP 5x telephoto lens with a tetraprism design for enhanced optical zoom.
  • Photography Performance: Both phones excel in everyday photography, capturing accurate colors and good dynamic range. The iPhone 16 Pro Max's larger sensors and advanced processing contribute to improved low-light performance and greater detail, especially with its upgraded ultra-wide camera. The 16 Pro Max also benefits from a 5x optical zoom, offering greater reach than the 15's 2x optical zoom.
  • Video Recording and Audio: Both devices support 4K video recording with features like Cinematic mode and Dolby Vision HDR. The iPhone 16 Pro Max further enhances video capabilities with support for 4K Dolby Vision up to 120fps, ProRes video recording, and Spatial video capture, making it a more robust tool for content creators. Both offer quality stereo speakers and microphone performance for calls and media.

Main camera

48 megapixels

48 megapixels

Front camera

12 megapixels

12 megapixels

Miscellaneous

Beyond core performance, several practical elements differentiate the user experience between these two iPhone models.

  • Connectivity: Both devices support 5G cellular connectivity and Bluetooth 5.3. The iPhone 15 features Wi-Fi 6, while the iPhone 16 Pro Max upgrades to Wi-Fi 7, offering potentially faster and more reliable wireless connections in compatible environments.
  • Ports and Sensors: Both models utilize a USB-C port for charging and data transfer. However, the iPhone 15's USB-C port operates at USB 2.0 speeds, whereas the iPhone 16 Pro Max features USB 3.0 speeds, enabling significantly faster data transfers. Both include Face ID for secure authentication. The iPhone 16 Pro Max introduces a new customizable Action Button and a dedicated Camera Control button, offering quick access to functions.
  • Physical Characteristics: The iPhone 15 has dimensions of 147.6 x 71.6 x 7.80 mm and weighs 171 grams. The iPhone 16 Pro Max is a larger and heavier device, measuring 163 x 77.6 x 8.25 mm and weighing 227 grams, which contributes to its larger screen and battery. The iPhone 16 Pro Max also features a titanium build, offering a different tactile experience compared to the iPhone 15's aluminum frame.

Weight

171 oz

7990 oz

Screen size (inches)

6.1

6.9

Network

5G

5G

SIM card

eSIM

eSIM

Carrier compatibility

AT&T

Unlocked

Connector

USB-C (USB 2)

USB-C (USB 3)

User sentiment for the iPhone 15 generally praises its significant camera upgrades over previous non-Pro models, the inclusion of the Dynamic Island, and the switch to USB-C, making it a well-rounded device for everyday use. Some users, however, noted its 60Hz display as a point of comparison to Pro models. For the iPhone 16 Pro Max, users frequently highlight its exceptional battery life, the expansive and fluid display, and the highly capable camera system as major advantages. Criticisms, though less common, sometimes point to its larger size and weight, which might not suit all preferences.

Users prioritizing a more compact form factor, a capable camera for general photography, and a device that offers a strong balance of features for daily tasks will find the iPhone 15 well-suited to their needs. It provides a premium experience without the larger dimensions of the Pro Max line. Conversely, individuals who demand the largest possible screen, the most advanced camera capabilities for photography and videography, extended battery life for heavy use, and the highest performance for demanding applications and gaming will lean towards the iPhone 16 Pro Max. Its ProMotion display and additional features cater to those seeking the most comprehensive iPhone experience.

For those considering either device, exploring quality-assured refurbished options can provide an eco-friendly alternative, extending the life cycle of these advanced smartphones.

See all articles

Our recent comparisons