Galaxy S23 Ultra • Unlocked vs Galaxy S24 Ultra • Unlocked

Galaxy S23 Ultra • Unlocked
Galaxy S23 Ultra • Unlocked
Starting at

Refurbished price:$373.00

Versus $1,199.99 new

See options
Galaxy S24 Ultra • Unlocked
Galaxy S24 Ultra • Unlocked
Starting at

Refurbished price:$612.00

Versus $1,399.00 new

See options

Ratings

The Samsung Galaxy S23 Ultra, released in February 2023, and the Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra, launched in January 2024, are both flagship Android smartphones from Samsung. While they share a similar design philosophy and core functionalities, the S24 Ultra introduces a more efficient processor, enhanced display brightness, and a suite of new AI-powered features, alongside a significant update to its software support policy. Both devices run on the Android operating system with Samsung's One UI overlay.

Scores

Durability

The durability of the Galaxy S23 Ultra and S24 Ultra shows incremental advancements, particularly in materials and software longevity. The S23 Ultra was released in February 2023, with the S24 Ultra following in January 2024, providing the latter with a longer potential software support window.

  • OS Support: The Galaxy S23 Ultra receives 4 years of major OS updates and 5 years of security patches, extending support until approximately 2027. The S24 Ultra offers 7 years of full software updates, pushing its support to 2031, making it a more enduring option for long-term software.
  • Build Materials: The S23 Ultra uses an Armor Aluminum frame and Gorilla Glass Victus 2. The S24 Ultra features a titanium frame for enhanced durability and fingerprint resistance. Its display is protected by Corning Gorilla Armor, designed for superior scratch and crack resistance and reduced reflections.
  • Practical Lifespan: Both devices boast an IP68 rating for dust and water resistance. While glass remains susceptible to drop damage, the S24 Ultra's flat display and advanced glass technology aim to provide improved impact resistance.

Release Year

2023

2024

Last OS Compatibility

Yes

Yes

OS

Android

Android

Foldable

No

No

Performance

The performance capabilities of the Galaxy S23 Ultra and S24 Ultra are both robust, though the newer model offers a generational leap in processing power.

  • Processing Power: The S23 Ultra's processor ensures smooth multitasking and gaming, handling demanding apps effectively. The S24 Ultra features a newer generation processor, providing a substantial generational leap in power, with higher benchmark scores in multi-core and graphics processing.
  • Real-world Responsiveness: For everyday use, both devices offer a fluid experience, with many users noting minimal difference in responsiveness for typical tasks. However, for intensive tasks like 4K 60fps video export, the S24 Ultra shows a slight advantage.
  • Memory and Storage: Both models offer similar storage options (256GB, 512GB, 1TB). The S23 Ultra typically has 8GB or 12GB of RAM, while the S24 Ultra consistently features 12GB of RAM in its base models, aiding smoother multitasking.

Memory

8 GB

12 GB

Screen quality

Both the Galaxy S23 Ultra and S24 Ultra feature impressive displays, though the S24 Ultra introduces notable enhancements in brightness and design.

  • Display Technology and Size: Both devices utilize a 6.8-inch QHD+ AMOLED display with a 120Hz adaptive refresh rate, providing vibrant colors and deep blacks. The S24 Ultra's display is flat, a change from the S23 Ultra's curved edges, which can improve S Pen usability and screen protector application.
  • Brightness and Clarity: The S23 Ultra offers a peak brightness of 1,750 nits. The S24 Ultra significantly boosts this to 2,600 nits, enhancing outdoor visibility. The S24 Ultra also features Gorilla Glass Armor, designed to reduce reflections by up to 75%, further improving outdoor legibility.
  • Viewing Experience: Both phones deliver exceptional detail and strong contrast with an adaptive refresh rate (1-120Hz) for smooth visuals and power efficiency.

Resolution

1440 x 3088

1440 x 3120

Screen type

Dynamic AMOLED 2X

Dynamic LTPO AMOLED 2X

Audiovisual

The camera systems on both the Galaxy S23 Ultra and S24 Ultra are highly capable, with the S24 Ultra introducing refinements, particularly in telephoto capabilities and image processing.

  • Rear Camera System: Both phones feature a 200MP main camera and a 12MP ultrawide. The S23 Ultra includes a 10MP 10x optical telephoto and a 10MP 3x optical telephoto. The S24 Ultra replaces the 10x telephoto with a 50MP 5x optical telephoto, retaining the 10MP 3x, and aiming for better low-light performance and stabilization.
  • Photography Performance: The S24 Ultra generally offers improved image exposure, more accurate contrast, and greater detail in bright areas. It also tends to produce cleaner images with less noise, especially when cropping or using digital zoom beyond 5x. The S24 Ultra's 50MP 5x telephoto is designed to achieve comparable or better quality at 10x zoom through computational photography.
  • Video and Audio: Both devices support 8K video recording at 30fps. The S24 Ultra's new 5x telephoto lens also enables 8K recording at 5x zoom. Both phones offer Dolby Atmos audio support.

Main camera

200 megapixels

200 megapixels

Front camera

12 megapixels

12 megapixels

Miscellaneous

The Galaxy S23 Ultra and S24 Ultra share many practical features, but the S24 Ultra introduces a new set of AI-powered functionalities and subtle design changes.

  • Connectivity and Ports: Both devices support 5G, Wi-Fi 802.11 a/b/g/n/ac/ax, and Bluetooth v5.30. They both feature a USB Type-C port for charging and data transfer.
  • Sensors and Biometrics: Both phones include an integrated S Pen stylus, offering similar design and functionality. They also feature advanced biometric security options like fingerprint and face recognition.
  • Design and Handling: The S23 Ultra has a slightly curved display and aluminum frame, while the S24 Ultra features a flat display and a titanium frame. The S24 Ultra is slightly lighter at 232g compared to the S23 Ultra's 234g, and has slightly different dimensions.
  • AI Features (S24 Ultra only): The S24 Ultra introduces Galaxy AI features like "Circle to Search," "Live Translate," "Note Assist," and "Generative Edit" for photos. These tools aim to enhance productivity, communication, and creative tasks.

Weight

8 oz

8 oz

Screen size (inches)

6.8

6.8

Network

5G

5G

SIM card

Physical SIM + eSIM

Physical SIM + eSIM

Carrier compatibility

Unlocked

Unlocked

User sentiment for both the Galaxy S23 Ultra and S24 Ultra is generally positive, with both devices praised for their premium feel, camera capabilities, and display quality. The S23 Ultra is lauded for its exceptional performance, camera system, and display, with S Pen integration being a significant advantage. Criticisms for the S23 Ultra include its large size and the curved screen making screen protectors difficult.

The S24 Ultra receives praise for its brighter screen, more powerful processor, and new titanium frame. Its extended software support of seven years is also a significant highlight for long-term ownership. However, some users note that the S24 Ultra's AI features, while innovative, might not be essential for everyone's daily use.

Users prioritizing the absolute latest technology, extended software support, and advanced AI features will find the Galaxy S24 Ultra well-suited. Its brighter, flat display and titanium build offer subtle but meaningful improvements. Conversely, users who value a proven, high-performance device with excellent camera capabilities and the S Pen, and who do not require the newest AI functionalities or longest software support, may find the Galaxy S23 Ultra a compelling option. Considering a quality-assured refurbished option for either model can provide an eco-friendly alternative for those seeking a sustainable choice.

See all articles

Our recent comparisons