iPhone 14 Pro Max • Locked AT&T vs iPhone 16 Plus • Unlocked

iPhone 14 Pro Max • Locked AT&T
iPhone 14 Pro Max • Locked AT&T
Starting at

Refurbished price:$409.00

Versus $1,399.00 new

See options
iPhone 16 Plus • Unlocked
iPhone 16 Plus • Unlocked
Starting at

Refurbished price:$575.98

Versus $829.00 new

See options

Ratings

The iPhone 14 Pro Max, released in September 2022, and the iPhone 16 Plus, launched in September 2024, represent different tiers and generations within Apple's smartphone lineup. While both offer large display experiences, the iPhone 16 Plus benefits from two years of technological advancements, bringing a newer processor, updated connectivity, and enhanced repairability. The iPhone 14 Pro Max, as a 'Pro' model of its generation, features a more advanced display and a dedicated telephoto camera, distinguishing it from the standard 'Plus' model of a later generation.

Scores

Durability

When considering the longevity of these devices, their respective release timelines and Apple's software support policies are key factors. The iPhone 14 Pro Max, launched in 2022, will receive iOS updates for a substantial period, typically around 5-6 years from its release. The iPhone 16 Plus, being a 2024 model, benefits from an extended software support window, likely receiving updates for at least one to two years longer than the 14 Pro Max.

  • Software Support: The iPhone 16 Plus, being newer, is expected to receive major iOS updates for a longer duration, extending its functional lifespan.
  • Repairability: The iPhone 16 Plus has a significantly improved repairability score of 7 out of 10, a notable increase from the iPhone 14 Pro Max's score, which was initially 6 out of 10 but later adjusted to 4 out of 10 due to software restrictions on parts. This suggests that the 16 Plus may be easier and more cost-effective to maintain over time.
  • Practical Lifespan: Both devices are built to last, but the newer internal design and enhanced repair options of the iPhone 16 Plus contribute to a potentially longer practical lifespan, especially for users who consider future maintenance.

Release Year

2022

2024

Last OS Compatibility

Yes

Yes

Foldable

No

No

Performance

Performance is a critical aspect for daily use, and both devices offer robust capabilities, though with generational differences. The iPhone 14 Pro Max is powered by a capable processor that handles demanding applications and multitasking smoothly. The iPhone 16 Plus, featuring a newer generation processor, offers enhanced speed and efficiency.

  • Processing Power: The iPhone 16 Plus benefits from a two-generation leap in processor technology, resulting in faster app loading times, smoother transitions, and more efficient handling of intensive tasks like advanced gaming or video editing.
  • Multitasking: While both devices manage multiple applications effectively, the iPhone 16 Plus, with its newer processor and potentially optimized software, provides a more responsive experience during heavy multitasking.
  • Battery Behavior: The iPhone 16 Plus is frequently noted for its exceptional battery life, often lasting longer than the iPhone 14 Pro Max, even under heavy usage. Users report the 16 Plus can often go for extended periods without needing a charge, making it suitable for users who prioritize maximum uptime.

Memory (GB)

6 GB

8 GB

Screen quality

The visual experience on both smartphones is immersive, though there are distinct differences in their display technologies and capabilities. Both feature large 6.7-inch OLED displays, providing vibrant colors and deep blacks.

  • Refresh Rate: The iPhone 14 Pro Max features ProMotion technology, offering an adaptive refresh rate that can go up to 120Hz, resulting in smoother scrolling and more fluid animations. The iPhone 16 Plus, in contrast, maintains a standard 60Hz refresh rate.
  • Brightness: The iPhone 14 Pro Max offers higher peak brightness levels, particularly for outdoor visibility, reaching up to 2000 nits. The iPhone 16 Plus provides ample brightness for most viewing conditions, but the 14 Pro Max has an edge in extremely bright environments.
  • Always-On Display: The iPhone 14 Pro Max includes an Always-On Display feature, allowing users to see essential information at a glance without fully waking the screen. This feature is not present on the iPhone 16 Plus.

Resolution

1290 x 2796

1290 x 2796

Screen type

LTPO Super Retina XDR OLED

Super Retina XDR OLED

Audiovisual

Both devices offer advanced camera systems capable of capturing high-quality photos and videos, but their configurations and specific strengths differ. The iPhone 14 Pro Max, as a 'Pro' model, includes a dedicated telephoto lens, while the iPhone 16 Plus focuses on an enhanced dual-camera setup.

  • Camera System: The iPhone 14 Pro Max features a triple-camera system with a 48MP main sensor, a 12MP ultra-wide lens, and a 12MP telephoto lens offering 3x optical zoom. The iPhone 16 Plus has a dual-camera system, including an upgraded 48MP main sensor and a 12MP ultra-wide lens with autofocus, enabling macro photography.
  • Photography Features: The 14 Pro Max excels with its optical zoom capabilities and advanced computational photography features like Photonic Engine. The 16 Plus introduces a new 'Camera Control' button for quicker access to camera settings and supports spatial photos and videos. Both offer strong low-light performance, though the 14 Pro Max's larger sensors and Pro features may offer a slight advantage in very challenging conditions.
  • Video Quality: Both phones record high-quality video, including 4K at various frame rates. The 14 Pro Max includes Cinematic Mode and Action Mode for stabilized video. The 16 Plus also offers excellent video stabilization and quality, with some Pro-level audio features for video.

Main camera

48 megapixels

48 megapixels

Front camera

12 megapixels

12 megapixels

Miscellaneous

Beyond core performance and display, several practical elements contribute to the overall user experience and differentiate these two large-screen iPhones. These include physical design, connectivity, and additional features.

  • Connectivity and Ports: The iPhone 14 Pro Max uses the Lightning port for charging and data transfer, and supports Wi-Fi 6. The iPhone 16 Plus has transitioned to a USB-C port, offering broader compatibility and potentially faster data transfer speeds, and supports the newer Wi-Fi 7 standard.
  • Physical Design and Handling: The iPhone 14 Pro Max weighs 240g, while the iPhone 16 Plus is lighter at 199g, which can impact long-term handling comfort for some users. Both devices feature Ceramic Shield front covers and IP68 water and dust resistance for durability.
  • Unique Features: The iPhone 14 Pro Max introduced the Dynamic Island, a pill-shaped cutout that dynamically displays alerts and background activities, a feature also present on the iPhone 16 Plus. The 16 Plus adds an Action Button, customizable for quick access to various functions, and a dedicated Camera Control button.

Weight

8 oz

7030 oz

Screen size (inches)

6.7

6.7

Network

5G

5G

SIM card

eSIM

eSIM

Carrier compatibility

AT&T

Unlocked

Connector

Lightning

USB-C (USB 2)

Choosing between the iPhone 14 Pro Max and the iPhone 16 Plus involves weighing the benefits of a previous generation's 'Pro' features against the advancements of a newer, standard 'Plus' model. User feedback for the iPhone 14 Pro Max often praises its robust build, exceptional battery life for its time, and the versatility of its triple camera system, particularly the optical zoom. Some users, however, noted its significant weight and the 3x telephoto zoom leaving them wanting more reach.

The iPhone 16 Plus is frequently lauded for its outstanding battery life, often described as class-leading, and its lighter design compared to previous large iPhones. Users appreciate the inclusion of the Action Button and the new Camera Control button for improved usability. Criticisms often point to the 60Hz display, which some find less fluid than higher refresh rate screens, and the absence of a dedicated telephoto lens.

Users prioritizing a smoother display experience with a 120Hz adaptive refresh rate and a dedicated optical zoom lens may find the iPhone 14 Pro Max better suited to their needs. Those who value extended battery life, a lighter device, the convenience of a USB-C port, and enhanced repairability will likely lean towards the iPhone 16 Plus. Both devices offer a premium smartphone experience, and considering a quality-assured refurbished option for either model can be an eco-friendly alternative for making an informed choice.

See all articles

Our recent comparisons