Galaxy Tab S9 Ultra (14.6", 2023) vs iPad Air 5 (2022, M1 series)

Galaxy Tab S9 Ultra (14.6", 2023)
Galaxy Tab S9 Ultra (14.6", 2023)
Starting at

Refurbished price:$580.05

Versus $1,200.00 new

See options
iPad Air 5 (2022, M1 series)
iPad Air 5 (2022, M1 series)
Starting at

Refurbished price:$297.00

Versus $599.00 new

See options

Ratings

The Samsung Galaxy Tab S9 Ultra, released in August 2023, and the Apple iPad Air (M1 series), launched in March 2022, represent distinct approaches to the premium tablet experience. While both devices offer powerful performance and versatile functionality, they differ significantly in display size, operating system, and ecosystem integration. The Galaxy Tab S9 Ultra runs on Android with Samsung's One UI, emphasizing a large, expansive display and multi-tasking capabilities, whereas the iPad Air operates on iPadOS, focusing on a balanced blend of portability and robust app support within Apple's ecosystem.

Scores

Durability

When considering the long-term usability of a tablet, factors such as software support, physical durability, and repairability are key. The release dates of these devices influence their expected software longevity and overall practical lifespan.

  • Software Updates: The Galaxy Tab S9 Ultra, being released in August 2023, is expected to receive major Android operating system updates for several years, typically four to five years from its launch, with security updates extending beyond that. The iPad Air (M1 series), launched in March 2022, benefits from Apple's consistent and generally longer software support, often receiving iPadOS updates for five to six years or more from its release date.
  • Physical Durability: The Galaxy Tab S9 Ultra features an Armor Aluminum build and boasts an IP68 rating for water and dust resistance, offering a higher degree of protection against environmental elements. The iPad Air (M1 series) utilizes an aluminum enclosure, providing a sturdy yet lighter construction, though it does not carry an official IP rating for water and dust resistance.
  • Repairability: Both devices are designed with internal components that require specialized tools and expertise for repair. The availability of parts and service options can vary by region and manufacturer policies, influencing the ease and cost of extending their practical lifespan through repairs.

Release Year

2023

2022

Last OS Compatibility

Yes

Yes

OS

Android

iPadOS

Performance

The core processing capabilities of a tablet dictate its responsiveness and ability to handle demanding applications and multitasking. Both the Galaxy Tab S9 Ultra and the iPad Air (M1 series) are equipped with powerful internal components designed for high performance.

  • Processing Power: The Galaxy Tab S9 Ultra features a current-generation octa-core processor, enabling it to manage intensive applications, complex multitasking, and graphics-rich gaming smoothly. The iPad Air (M1 series) incorporates a powerful chip with an 8-core CPU and an 8-core GPU, delivering desktop-class performance suitable for professional-grade video editing, advanced graphic design, and running multiple demanding applications simultaneously.
  • Multitasking and Responsiveness: With up to 16GB of RAM in some configurations, the Galaxy Tab S9 Ultra offers substantial memory for seamless app switching and running numerous applications side-by-side without noticeable slowdowns. The iPad Air (M1 series) comes with 8GB of RAM, which, combined with iPadOS optimizations, provides a highly responsive user experience for most multitasking scenarios and demanding workflows.
  • Storage Options: The Galaxy Tab S9 Ultra offers flexible storage configurations up to 1TB, with the added benefit of expandable storage via a microSD card, allowing users to significantly increase their digital space. The iPad Air (M1 series) provides internal storage options of 64GB and 256GB, which are fixed and not expandable.

Memory (GB)

12 GB

8 GB

Screen quality

The display is a primary interface for any tablet, and both devices offer high-quality visual experiences, though with distinct characteristics in size and technology.

  • Display Technology and Size: The Galaxy Tab S9 Ultra boasts a large 14.6-inch Dynamic AMOLED 2X display, providing deep blacks, vibrant colors, and excellent contrast, making it well-suited for immersive media consumption and detailed work. The iPad Air (M1 series) features a 10.9-inch Liquid Retina IPS LCD display, known for its accurate color reproduction and wide viewing angles, offering a balanced visual experience in a more compact form factor.
  • Resolution and Clarity: The Galaxy Tab S9 Ultra's display has a resolution of 2960 x 1848 pixels, delivering sharp images and text across its expansive screen. The iPad Air (M1 series) offers a resolution of 2360 x 1640 pixels, ensuring crisp visuals on its smaller screen.
  • Refresh Rate and Brightness: The Galaxy Tab S9 Ultra features a 120Hz refresh rate, contributing to smoother scrolling and more fluid animations, with a peak brightness that enhances visibility in various lighting conditions. The iPad Air (M1 series) operates at a standard 60Hz refresh rate and offers a brightness of 500 nits, which is sufficient for indoor and most outdoor use.

Resolution

1848 x 2960

2360 x 1640

Screen type

Dynamic AMOLED 2X

Liquid Retina display

Pixel density

240ppp

264ppp

Audiovisual

While tablets are not typically primary photography devices, their camera systems are increasingly important for video calls, document scanning, and casual photography. Both tablets offer capable camera setups for these purposes.

  • Rear Camera System: The Galaxy Tab S9 Ultra includes a dual rear camera setup with a 13MP wide lens and an 8MP ultrawide lens, providing versatility for different photographic situations and document capture. The iPad Air (M1 series) features a single 12MP wide rear camera, capable of capturing detailed photos and 4K video.
  • Front Camera for Video Conferencing: The Galaxy Tab S9 Ultra stands out with a dual front camera system, featuring a 12MP wide and a 12MP ultrawide lens, which is beneficial for high-quality video calls and accommodating multiple participants. The iPad Air (M1 series) is equipped with a 12MP ultrawide front camera that supports Center Stage, a feature that automatically keeps the user in frame during video calls, enhancing the video conferencing experience.
  • Video Recording and Audio: Both devices are capable of recording video in 4K resolution, with the Galaxy Tab S9 Ultra supporting up to 4K at 60fps for both front and rear cameras, and the iPad Air also offering 4K at 60fps on its rear camera. The Galaxy Tab S9 Ultra features quad stereo speakers tuned by AKG with Dolby Atmos support, delivering a rich audio experience. The iPad Air also provides stereo speakers, suitable for media consumption and calls.

Miscellaneous

Beyond the core specifications, several practical elements contribute to the overall user experience, including connectivity, physical design, and additional features.

  • Connectivity and Ports: The Galaxy Tab S9 Ultra supports Wi-Fi 6E and Bluetooth 5.3, offering advanced wireless connectivity and faster data transfer speeds. It includes a USB-C 3.2 port for charging and data. The iPad Air (M1 series) features Wi-Fi 6 and Bluetooth 5.0, providing reliable wireless connections, and a USB-C port that supports USB 3.1 Gen 2 for faster data transfer. Both devices offer optional 5G cellular connectivity in certain models and regions.
  • Dimensions and Handling: The Galaxy Tab S9 Ultra is a larger device, measuring 326.4 x 208.6 x 5.5 mm and weighing around 732g (Wi-Fi model), which provides an expansive workspace but can be more substantial to handle. The iPad Air (M1 series) is more compact and lighter at 247.6 x 178.5 x 6.1 mm and approximately 461g (Wi-Fi model), making it more portable and easier for one-handed use.
  • Stylus and Biometrics: The Galaxy Tab S9 Ultra includes an S Pen in the box, which is IP68 rated and offers a natural writing and drawing experience. It features an in-display fingerprint sensor for secure authentication. The iPad Air (M1 series) supports the Apple Pencil 2nd Gen, which is sold separately, and integrates Touch ID into its top button for biometric security.

Weight

15 oz

16 oz

Screen size (inches)

14.6

10.9

Network

Wi-Fi

Wi-Fi

Carrier compatibility

Without SIM Port

Without SIM Port

Choosing between the Galaxy Tab S9 Ultra and the iPad Air (M1 series) depends heavily on individual priorities and intended use cases. Both tablets offer robust performance and high-quality displays, but cater to different preferences in terms of size, operating system, and ecosystem.

Users frequently praise the Galaxy Tab S9 Ultra for its expansive and vibrant AMOLED display, which is ideal for media consumption, digital art, and productivity tasks requiring a large screen. Its included S Pen and desktop-like DeX mode are often highlighted as significant advantages for those seeking a laptop-replacement experience. Some users, however, find its large size can make it less portable for casual, on-the-go use. The Android ecosystem, while versatile, may also present a different app experience compared to iPadOS for certain professional applications.

The iPad Air (M1 series) is commonly lauded for its balanced combination of portability, powerful performance, and the refined iPadOS experience. Its M1 chip is frequently cited for delivering exceptional speed and efficiency, making it a strong contender for demanding creative tasks and gaming. The robust app ecosystem of iPadOS is also a consistent point of praise. Some users note that its smaller screen size, compared to the Tab S9 Ultra, might be less ideal for extensive multitasking or immersive viewing, and the separate purchase of the Apple Pencil adds to the overall investment.

Users prioritizing a large, high-refresh-rate OLED display, an included stylus, and a more desktop-like Android experience with expandable storage may find the Galaxy Tab S9 Ultra better suited to their needs. Conversely, individuals who value a more compact and lightweight design, a highly optimized operating system with a vast app library, and consistent long-term software support might lean towards the iPad Air (M1 series). Both devices offer compelling features, and considering a quality-assured refurbished option for either can be a sustainable choice for consumers.

See all articles

Our recent comparisons